Napa Valley Features

Napa Valley Features

Under the Hood: St. Helena Answered the Grand Jury and Moved the Deadlines. The Water Didn’t Wait.

By Tim Carl

Oct 15, 2026
∙ Paid

Support Independent Local News:

Napa Valley Features depends on paid subscriptions to support our local reporting and community information. Now in our fourth year, we are also building new tools and resources at NapaServe.org.

Please consider becoming a paid subscriber, renewing or joining as a founding member. We could not do this work without your support.

The Council does not dispute that the distribution system has real, unresolved problems …

— City of St. Helena, response to the 2025-2026 Napa County Civil Grand Jury report

The Spotlight:

Welcome to Under the Hood, our exclusive weekly series for Napa Valley Features paid subscribers.

Summary of Today’s Article: St. Helena’s City Council has filed its formal answer to a Napa County Civil Grand Jury report that blamed the city’s water problems on governance failures. The response, dated Sept. 18 and signed by Mayor Paul Dohring, partially disagrees with all seven of the report’s findings, describes four of its five recommendations as requiring further analysis and rejects the report’s characterization of the C

ouncil’s governance. Records obtained by Napa Valley Features show the city’s legal basis for declining one recommendation rests on a memo written a year earlier about a single customer. It is not the first time the city has answered a grand jury on rates and contracts: Of its 2,019 responses, the following year’s jury found 10 did not follow the format state law requires.

Beyond today’s discussion, we’re also digging into the latest results from our reader polls and pulling a few takeaways from our local economic dashboard.

A laboratory beaker of yellow-tinged water on a porch railing at a St. Helena home
Water drawn from the copper line entering Robb McDonough’s St. Helena home, before his under-sink filter and after the morning’s water use, Oct. 13— Robb McDonough Photo
User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Napa Valley Features.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Napa Valley Features · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.